---
title: "The Initiative on Basic Rules for Agent Authorization and Interoperability (智能体授权互操作基础规则倡议, V1.0): Ten Principles and Ten Questions, in Full"
author: "DCC Editorial"
published: 2026-11-12T09:15:00.000Z
url: https://datacompliancechina.com/posts/agent-authorization-interoperability-basic-rules-initiative/
description: "A full translation of the operative text. The Initiative on Basic Rules for Agent Authorization and Interoperability (智能体授权互操作基础规则倡议), version V1.0, was released on November 7, 2026 at Zhejiang University's Sixth Forum on Rule of Law and Reform. It was initiated by the Zhejiang University Institute of Digital Rule of Law with sixteen co-initiators, mostly university research centers and law firms, drafted by twenty-six named experts, and published on Li Wenlong's 科技利维坦 channel. It is voluntary and binds only those who join. Its ten principles are autonomous authorization, proportionate interoperability, transparent rules, open standards, reasonable non-discrimination, equal treatment, fair competition, functional reciprocity, multi-party co-governance and effective remedy. Its ten questions and answers take positions on the live disputes: a user's authorization does not by itself oblige a third-party service to allow access; a service's failure to declare a refusal is not legal consent; reduced ad exposure or entry-point competition alone does not justify a restriction; identical rule text does not prove non-discrimination; and the Initiative cannot itself require any company to open an interface. DCC reads it against MIIT's Notice 工信厅信管〔2026〕42号, published one day earlier."
tags: ["ai-agents", "agent-authorization", "interoperability", "soft-law", "industry-initiative", "non-discrimination", "functional-reciprocity", "saep", "zhejiang-university", "platform-governance"]
laws_cited: ["miit-agent-terminal-network-access-notice", "ai-agent-standardization-innovation-opinion"]
domains: ["ai-governance", "data-economy"]
account: "keji-leviathan"
original_title: "智能体授权互操作基础规则倡议"
original_author: "浙江大学数字法治研究院等发起单位；李汶龙 (Li Wenlong) 发布"
original_publication: "科技利维坦 WeChat Official Account"
original_url: "https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/Qm4W9vRa41Fpny4AI6B5WQ"
source_language: "zh"
---

> **Source: Data Compliance China** — https://datacompliancechina.com/posts/agent-authorization-interoperability-basic-rules-initiative/ · China data law, translated and annotated for overseas counsel. Cite as: Data Compliance China, "The Initiative on Basic Rules for Agent Authorization and Interoperability (智能体授权互操作基础规则倡议, V1.0): Ten Principles and Ten Questions, in Full", https://datacompliancechina.com/posts/agent-authorization-interoperability-basic-rules-initiative/
> *Editor's Note — DCC.*
>
> **What this is.** A voluntary initiative (倡议), not a law, a standard or
> a regulator's document. It binds no one who has not joined it, and says so.
> DCC translates it because it is the first multi-institution statement in
> China of what the rules between an AI agent, the user who authorizes it
> and the app it operates ought to be, and because it appeared the day after
> MIIT's
> [Agent Terminal Notice](/laws/miit-agent-terminal-network-access-notice/)
> (工信厅信管〔2026〕42号) settled one of those questions by rule.
>
> **Where it comes from.** It is the "consensus declaration" Li Wenlong
> announced at the end of his essay on the SAEP refusals, translated in
> [The Agent Authorization Standoff After SAEP](/posts/agent-authorization-standoff-saep-interoperability-rules/).
>
> **The source and the translation.** The WeChat post carries the
> Initiative as nine page images with no text layer. DCC read them by OCR
> and checked the result against the images. The ten principles and the ten
> questions and answers are translated in full, as are the front-matter
> sections. The list of drafting experts is given by name and affiliation;
> honorifics and secondary titles are shortened. The contact address for
> joining is in the original and is not reproduced here. English names of
> institutions are DCC's renderings unless the institution uses one of its
> own.

# Initiative on Basic Rules for Agent Authorization and Interoperability

*智能体授权互操作基础规则倡议 · Version V1.0*

## Front matter

### I. Purpose of the Initiative

This Initiative aims to promote trusted interoperability of agents across
applications, platforms and ecosystems and, on the basis of respecting
users' autonomous choice, safeguarding lawful rights and interests and
maintaining security and fair competition, to advance the building of open,
non-discriminatory and transparent interoperability rules and mechanisms for
compatibility and mutual recognition.

### II. Who it is addressed to

This Initiative is addressed to those who take part in agent
interoperability and in the related rule-making, technical implementation
and governance work, including but not limited to:

1. **Agent service providers:** those who develop, deploy or operate agents
   or provide related agency services.
2. **Application and service operators:** those who provide applications,
   platforms, digital services and related resources that agents can access,
   invoke or operate.
3. **Terminal and system providers:** those who provide smart terminals,
   operating systems, runtime environments, identity authentication,
   permission management or policy enforcement capabilities.
4. **Technical protocol and infrastructure providers:** those who provide
   interoperability protocols, interface standards, authentication, tool
   calling and other technical support.
5. **Other relevant parties:** including industry associations,
   standardization organizations, research institutions, representatives of
   users and of consumer interests, and other organizations or individuals
   taking part in research, standard-setting, technical evaluation, industry
   collaboration and the promotion of practice in agent interoperability.

### III. Scenarios covered

This Initiative applies mainly to conduct in which an agent, on the basis of
the user's valid authorization, accesses digital resources, processes
information and performs tasks across applications, platforms or services
by screen interaction, application interfaces, tool calling or other
technical means. Specifically, it covers agent identity recognition,
authorization and permission management, the expression of access
conditions, policy negotiation and enforcement, risk control, operation
records, verification of results, dispute handling and cooperation on
liability.

### IV. How to take part

This Initiative is published openly and participation is voluntary. Those
wishing to take part may submit their intention through the participation
registration channel. *[A contact address follows in the original.]*

### V. Release and effect

This Initiative was formally released on November 7, 2026 at the Sixth Forum
on Rule of Law and Reform (第六届法治与改革论坛) held at Zhejiang
University, in the sub-forum "Legislative Choices and Rule Design for
Agents" (智能体的立法选择与规则设计).

### VI. Revision

The initiating unit is responsible for organizing day-to-day communication,
the collection of opinions, coordination of implementation and version
maintenance for this Initiative. Later revisions shall adhere to the
principles of openness, transparency and multi-party participation, and
shall fully hear the views of agent providers, application operators,
terminal and system providers, user representatives and other stakeholders.
Major revisions shall in principle be accompanied by a reasonable
consultation and transition arrangement.

### VII. Participating bodies

**Initiating unit:** Zhejiang University Institute of Digital Rule of Law
(浙江大学数字法治研究院).

**Co-initiating units,** as listed in the original:

- Research Center for Digital Economy and Legal Innovation, University of
  International Business and Economics (对外经济贸易大学数字经济与法律创新研究中心)
- Shanghai Collaborative Innovation Center for AI Social Governance, Tongji
  University (同济大学上海市人工智能社会治理协同创新中心)
- Global AI Innovative Governance Center (全球人工智能创新治理中心)
- Research Center for AI and Information Security Law, Xi'an Jiaotong
  University (西安交通大学人工智能与信息安全法律研究中心)
- MIIT Key Laboratory of Smart Rule of Law for Industry and Information
  Technology (工业和信息化智慧法治工信部重点实验室)
- Zhejiang University Institute of Digital Rule of Law (listed again among
  the co-initiators)
- Hainan University Law School (海南大学法学院)
- Institute of AI Law, China University of Political Science and Law
  (中国政法大学人工智能法研究院)
- Data Law Research Center, East China University of Political Science and
  Law (华东政法大学数据法律研究中心)
- King & Wood Mallesons, Beijing (北京市金杜律师事务所)
- Jinan University Law School (暨南大学法学院)
- Shihui Partners, Beijing (北京世辉律师事务所)
- Research Center for Competition Law and Intellectual Property, Shanghai
  University of Finance and Economics (上海财经大学竞争法与知识产权研究中心)
- Tahota Law Firm (泰和泰律师事务所)
- Center for AI Governance and Law, Shanghai Jiao Tong University
  (上海交通大学人工智能治理与法律研究中心)
- Zhejiang Kending Law Firm (浙江垦丁律师事务所)
- Institute of Law and Technology, Shenzhen University
  (深圳大学法律与科技研究院)

**Drafting experts** (26, in the original's alphabetical order by pinyin):

| Name | Affiliation as listed |
|---|---|
| Cao Jianfeng (曹建峰) | Shenzhen University Law School |
| Chen Tianhao (陈天昊) | Tsinghua University School of Public Policy and Management; Tsinghua Center for Science and Technology Development and Governance |
| Feng Yang (冯洋) | Zhejiang University Guanghua Law School; ZJU Institute of Public Law and Comparative Law |
| Gao Fuping (高富平) | East China University of Political Science and Law, data rule-of-law research center |
| Li Wenlong (李汶龙) | Zhejiang University Guanghua Law School; member of a UNESCO AI ethics committee |
| Li Zhenhua (李振华) | Ant Group Research Institute |
| Liao Huaixue (廖怀学) | Tahota Law Firm; Renmin University Law School (doctoral candidate) |
| Liu Xiaochun (刘晓春) | University of Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Internet Rule of Law Research Center |
| Ma Ce (麻策) | Kending Law Firm |
| Ma Changshan (马长山) | East China University of Political Science and Law, Institute of Digital Rule of Law |
| Pan Ning (潘宁) | Jinan University Law School |
| Wang Xinlei (王新雷) | Xi'an Jiaotong University Law School; Research Center for AI and Information Security Law |
| Wang Xinrui (王新锐) | Shihui Partners |
| Wu Han (吴涵) | King & Wood Mallesons |
| Wu Peicheng (吴佩乘) | Zhejiang University Guanghua Law School |
| Xu Ke (许可) | University of International Business and Economics Law School |
| Yang Fang (杨芳) | Hainan University Law School |
| Yao Xu (姚旭) | Global AI Innovative Governance Center; Fudan Development Institute |
| Yuan Bo (袁波) | Shanghai University of Finance and Economics |
| Zhang Jiyu (张吉豫) | Renmin University Law School; Institute for Future Rule of Law |
| Zhang Linghan (张凌寒) | China University of Political Science and Law, Institute of AI Law |
| Zhang Weijun (张伟君) | Zhejiang University Guanghua Law School |
| Zhang Xin (张欣) | University of International Business and Economics Law School |
| Zhao Jingwu (赵精武) | MIIT Key Laboratory of Smart Rule of Law for Industry and Information Technology |
| Zhao Zerui (赵泽睿) | Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Center for AI Governance and Law |
| Zhu Lingfeng (朱玲凤) | Legal expert at an internet company |

**Acknowledgments.** From drafting to final text, this Initiative went
through many rounds of discussion and revision, and benefited from the
wisdom and support of many people from industry, academia, legal practice,
technical standards and related fields of public policy research. Special
thanks go to Hong Yanqing (洪延青), Zhu Yue (朱悦), Xu Peng (徐鹏), Hu
Naying (呼娜英), Xu Gang (徐钢), Fu Hongyu (傅宏宇), Kang Weibing (康维兵),
Wu Shaoqing (吴少卿) and other experts and scholars (in no particular order)
for their professional support and careful advice. In addition, some
experts, industry colleagues and other participants were unable or found it
inconvenient to sign publicly, by reason of professional duties,
institutional requirements, work arrangements or otherwise, but made
important contributions to the conception of the rules, the technical
argument and the coordination of multiple interests. We fully respect their
wishes as to attribution and the related confidentiality requirements, and
extend sincere thanks for the trust, support and professional commitment
they have given. We look forward to continuing, on the basis of mutual
respect and open collaboration, to bring together the experience of all
parties and jointly to advance the continuing improvement of the rules for
agent authorization and interoperability.

**Version number:** V1.0

---

## The ten principles

### 1. Autonomous authorization (自主授权)

An agent accesses third-party services within the scope of its lawful
permissions, on the basis of the user's genuine, explicit and valid
authorization or of another basis expressly provided by law. The agent's
agency permissions shall be commensurate with the rights the user enjoys by
law and the scope of what the user may authorize, and are subject to the
provisions of law on personal information protection, cybersecurity,
transaction security and other matters.

An agent's acts of agency shall make clear the authorizing party, the
matter, the scope of permission and the duration, and shall support the
user in querying, adjusting, suspending and withdrawing them. For operations
involving identity authentication, control of physical devices, major
disposals of property, personal safety and the like, mechanisms for separate
confirmation, user takeover or limits on automatic execution shall be set
according to risk.

### 2. Proportionate interoperability (适度互操作)

It is advocated that a proportionate balance be sought among users'
reasonable use, the opening of services and security safeguards: providing
agents with the access and operating capability necessary to complete
authorized tasks, while fully respecting the security, resources and
reasonable business needs of third-party services.

All parties are encouraged to set the scope of access, execution permissions
and conditions for continuous operation reasonably, according to the nature
of the task, the degree of interoperability and the actual risk; to give
priority to exploring flexible measures such as graded authorization,
capability limits and user confirmation; and to reduce unnecessary obstacles
to access while safeguarding security.

### 3. Transparent rules (规则透明)

It is advocated that the access conditions, restrictive measures and related
rules of agent interoperability be open, transparent, clear and easy to
understand, so that all participants can reasonably anticipate the
conditions of access and collaboration.

The relevant parties are encouraged to provide appropriate explanations and
complaint channels for important restrictions, and to communicate major rule
changes in advance, leaving all parties a reasonable time to adjust and
adapt.

### 4. Open standards (开放标准)

It is advocated that, on the basis of existing open protocols and technical
standards, standardization and compatible mutual recognition be advanced in
key links such as agent identity recognition, authorization credentials,
capability description and task interaction, so as to promote coordinated
operation among different agents, terminals and application services.

The adoption of open and extensible technical specifications is encouraged,
supporting connection between different technical paths and equivalent
implementations, and lowering the adaptation cost of cross-platform and
cross-ecosystem collaboration.

### 5. Reasonable non-discrimination (合理非歧视)

All parties shall follow the principle of reasonable non-discrimination and
promote fair access by agents to the relevant services in accordance with
laws and regulations. Third-party service operators may set reasonable
conditions such as identity authentication, permission management, call
frequency and fee arrangements, on the basis of legitimate needs such as
account security, legal compliance, system capacity, reasonable cost and the
order of transactions. The conditions shall have an objective basis and be
commensurate with the actual risk and the resources consumed.

### 6. Equal treatment (平等待遇)

In making and implementing agent interoperability rules, reasonable
commercial arrangements and security-management needs shall be respected,
and fair and foreseeable conditions of cooperation created for those taking
part in cross-platform and cross-service collaboration.

Parties that hold the relevant access or rule-enforcement capability are
encouraged to offer fair and reasonable opportunities for cooperation in
comparable scenarios and under comparable risk conditions, to reduce
unnecessary technical and ecosystem barriers, and to promote innovation and
healthy competition.

### 7. Fair competition (公平竞争)

It is advocated that an open and fair environment for agent interoperability
be fostered, that all parties' reasonable commercial arrangements and
security-management needs be respected, and that different players take part
fairly and compete healthily in cross-platform and cross-ecosystem
collaboration.

Parties that hold key interfaces, terminal entry points or ecosystem
resources are encouraged to set access conditions reasonably, to take
account both of their own business interests and of other participants'
opportunities to innovate, and to reduce unnecessary barriers to competition
by means such as transparent negotiation and reasonable restriction.

### 8. Functional reciprocity (功能互惠)

It is advocated that agent providers, terminal and system providers and
third-party service operators each bring their strengths to bear and, on the
basis of voluntary negotiation, form reciprocal cooperation mechanisms
commensurate with technical capability, resources invested and risk borne.

The parties promote interoperability through capability sharing, technical
collaboration and shared responsibility. Reciprocity lies in a reasonable
balance of contribution and responsibility in cooperation, not in requiring
the parties to open the same resources or provide equivalent services.

### 9. Multi-party co-governance (多方共治)

Agent providers, third-party service operators, terminal manufacturers,
standards organizations, user representatives and professional institutions
are encouraged to take part together in making and improving rules on agent
access, the enforcement of authorization, risk management and the
coordination of disputes, and guidance from the competent authorities is
welcomed. It is advocated that rule-making, enforcement and evaluation be
coordinated with one another and appropriately separated in function.

Connection with domestic and international standards organizations,
industry collaboration mechanisms and related governance dialogues is
encouraged, to promote the exchange of practical experience and reduce
unnecessary fragmentation of ecosystems.

### 10. Effective remedy (有效救济)

It is advocated that convenient and transparent mechanisms for handling
interoperability disputes be established, giving users and the relevant
participants channels for feedback, verification and correction on problems
such as access restrictions and abnormal execution.

The relevant participants should make clear how matters are received and
answered, and cooperate promptly to verify key facts and correct problems
that have been found. For major or continuing disputes, the introduction of
an independent third party to carry out technical evaluation and
coordination may be explored.

---

## Questions and answers on the core content of the Initiative

**Question 1. After a user authorizes an agent, must a third-party service
allow access?**

Not as a matter of course. The access conditions for reasonable use of a
service already obtained, for continuous execution across pages, and for
commercial aggregation across services are different. Whether there is a
specific obligation to grant access is to be judged by law, by valid
contracts, and by the commitments undertaken on expressly joining this
Initiative.

**Question 2. If a third-party service has not declared a refusal, does that
amount to permission?**

No. A default of no restriction at the protocol level does not as a matter
of course constitute consent or permission in law, or authorization of a
specific transaction. A third-party service's silence, lack of adaptation or
failure to object is not the same concept as legal consent, permission for
access, or authorization for a specific use of data.

**Question 3. May an operator restrict agents on commercial grounds?**

Reasonable service cost, carrying capacity and the order of transactions may
be taken into account. But competition over the entry point, or reduced
advertising exposure, is not by itself enough to support a restriction, and
contracts, competition law and commitments already made on fair access must
still be observed.

**Question 4. Must all agents receive exactly the same treatment?**

No. Agents that are similar in scope of authorization, technical capability,
risk and trust conditions should receive fair treatment; real differences
can support graded requirements that have a basis.

**Question 5. How can a continuously running agent be kept within its
authorization at all times?**

A continuous task may run on explicit authorization. But where the object of
the task, the amount, the use of data or similar matters change materially,
or the operation enters a higher risk level, there should be fresh
verification, confirmation or an offer of user takeover according to risk,
and repeated execution should be guarded against. A withdrawal of
authorization should also be passed on to downstream tasks not yet executed.
For a high-risk operation whose result is unclear, the status should be
checked first, to avoid executing it again.

**Question 6. Does reciprocity mean that every party must open the same
resources?**

It does not. Functional reciprocity stresses that rights and
responsibilities, investment and risk should be commensurate. It does not
require the same resources to be opened, and it may not be used to exclude
new entrants.

**Question 7. How is one to judge whether a restriction is reasonable?**

By an overall assessment of the legitimate purpose, the evidence of risk,
the effectiveness of the measure, less intrusive alternatives, the effect on
users and the market, and the conditions for lifting it.

**Question 8. Is identical rule text enough to prove non-discrimination?**

It is not. One must also compare identity authentication, the opening of
capabilities, the actual path of policy enforcement, service quality and the
outcome of remedies.

**Question 9. How are disputes to be resolved and liability for harm
determined?**

The relevant parties first verify the authorization, the policy and the
execution records under an open procedure, bringing in independent review
where necessary. Liability for harm is determined according to law and
contract, in light of the specific conduct, system defects, capacity for
control, fault and causation. Participants should agree in advance on a
collaborative process for receiving incidents, stopping loss, preserving
evidence, verifying results and sharing reasonable costs.

**Question 10. Can this Initiative directly require a company to open its
interfaces?**

It cannot. This Initiative can create contractual obligations through
voluntary accession. Mandatory opening by operation of law requires a
separate, express basis and the satisfaction of the corresponding statutory
conditions.

---

## DCC's reading

*The notes below are DCC's, not the Initiative's.*

- **On silence, the Initiative and MIIT now agree.** Question 2 says a
  service's failure to declare a refusal is not consent. That is a rejection
  of the opt-out premise of Doubao's SAEP. Part I, item (4) of
  [工信厅信管〔2026〕42号](/laws/miit-agent-terminal-network-access-notice/)
  reaches the same result by rule: no declared consent, no forcible
  invocation.
- **On reasons, the Initiative goes where the Notice does not.** The Notice
  asks only whether the app developer has declared consent. Principles 5 to
  7 and Questions 3, 7 and 8 ask whether a refusal or a condition has an
  objective basis, and say that lost ad exposure alone is not one. None of
  this binds an app developer that has not joined.
- **It is drafted as soft law on purpose.** Almost every operative sentence
  is "advocated" (倡导) or "encouraged" (鼓励). The main exceptions, where
  the text says "shall" (应), are Principle 1 on the content and
  revocability of the user's authorization, Principle 5 on the objective
  basis for conditions, and the opening sentence of Principle 6. Question 10
  states the limit: obligations arise by joining, as contract.
- **Who has signed, and who has not.** The initiators are university
  research centers and law firms. Two drafting experts are listed from
  industry: one from Ant Group's research institute, and one described as a
  legal expert at an internet company. The list published with V1.0 names no handset
  maker, app platform or agent provider as an initiating unit. Whether any
  of them join will decide whether the Initiative matters in practice.
- **For users' personal information,** Principle 1 subjects the agent's
  permissions to personal information protection law. For how consent under
  the [PIPL](/laws/pipl/) strains when an agent reads the screen, see
  [AI Agents and the Limits of Consent](/posts/ai-agents-and-the-limits-of-consent/).

— *智能体授权互操作基础规则倡议 (Initiative on Basic Rules for Agent
Authorization and Interoperability), V1.0, released November 7, 2026;
published by 科技利维坦 on November 9, 2026. Initiating unit: Zhejiang
University Institute of Digital Rule of Law. Translated by DCC from the page
images in the original post.
[Original (Chinese).](https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/Qm4W9vRa41Fpny4AI6B5WQ)*

*Names and affiliations are as listed in the original; romanizations and
English institution names are DCC's and may differ from those the persons
and institutions use themselves.*

— Not legal advice.
