Filed under article-71
Every brief tagged "article-71".
- § 01 · ENFORCEMENT
What the Cybersecurity Law Actually Costs
An empirical read of 6,214 Cybersecurity Law administrative penalty decisions published between January 1, 2025 and July 1, 2026. Three findings for overseas counsel. First, the enforcement machine is police-led and district-level: 98.3% of decisions come from public security organs, 61% from county and district bureaus, and the Cyberspace Administration appears four times in 6,214 cases. Second, the statute runs two tracks that behave oppositely — the obligations track (Arts. 21 and 25 via Art. 59) ends in a warning 94–95% of the time and fines roughly one case in forty, while the conduct track (Art. 27 via Art. 63, Art. 44 via Art. 64) detains or fines in essentially every case, because Art. 59 makes the fine conditional on refusal to rectify while Art. 64 ¶2 mandates one to ten times illegal gains. Third, the money is trivial and top-heavy: RMB 179.35 million total, of which the single Kuaishou penalty is 66.4%, leaving a median fine of RMB 1,800 across the remaining 1,923 fined decisions, and 69% of decisions carry no monetary penalty at all. Plus the transition trap: the 2025 amendment renumbered every article above — 'Article 27' now means the opposite thing — and deleted the CSL's own personal-information penalty, the provision behind 20.4% of all enforcement, referring it out under new Article 71.