Filed under national-intelligence-law
Every brief tagged "national-intelligence-law".
- § 01 · DEEPSEEK
The Questions Chinese Law Would Have to Answer: A January 2025 Reading of DeepSeek, the Garante, and Why EU Paperwork Cannot Fix Data Localization
A DCC summary, not a translation, of a 科技利维坦 (Li Wenlong) post dated January 31, 2025, written days after Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, questioned and then blocked DeepSeek. The post reads DeepSeek's position as a replay of OpenAI's in 2023, sets out what a minimum EU privacy posture for a large model looked like at the time, and identifies the one difference that compliance work cannot close: user data stored in China. Its China-facing conclusion is that EU documents and mechanisms do not solve localization. Trust would need clarity, in Chinese law, on the three data laws (CSL, DSL, PIPL) read with the National Intelligence Law, on the legal status of the Cyberspace Administration of China and the legal nature of the documents it issues, on due process when public bodies access data held by private companies, and on the remedies available to foreigners under the Civil Code and the PIPL. DCC sets out those four questions for counsel who are asked them from the other direction. The post predates everything after January 2025 and DCC has not updated its facts.